18 Of Best Pie Pastry Fillings In 2024

TOP 1

Libby's 100% Pure Pumpkin, 15-Ounce

Libby's
LB-PPF
6.00 x 5.00 x 4.00 inches
7.52 pounds

Our Score

4.95
TOP 2

Green Valley Organics Pumpkin | Certified Organic

Green Valley
6.00 x 6.00 x 6.00 inches
4.00 pounds

Our Score

4.9
TOP 3

Solo Poppy Seed Cake & Pastry Filling 2 Pack

Unknown
041642001109
1.70 pounds

Our Score

4.8
TOP 4

Henry & Henry Bavarian Cream Pastry and Cake Filling

Henry
1018M5QV1NM
17.00 x 3.50 x 0.75 inches
2.00 pounds

Our Score

4.75
TOP 5

Henry & Henry Red Raspberry Pastry and Cake Filling

Henry
17.00 x 3.50 x 0.75 inches
2.00 pounds

Our Score

4.75
TOP 6

Cross & Blackwell Rum and Brandy Mincemeat Pie Filling and Topping

Crosse & Blackwell

Our Score

4.7
TOP 7

Jell-O Instant Butterscotch Sugar-Free Fat Free Pudding & Pie Filling

Jell-O
00043000076576
2.75 x 3.38 x 8.00 inches
0.02 pounds

Our Score

4.7
TOP 8

None Such, Mincemeat Clsc Original

None Such
12342
13.50 x 10.10 x 6.70 inches
1.69 pounds

Our Score

4.65
TOP 9

Libby's 100% Pure Pumpkin 3 PK 29oz. Cans

Libby's
3.00 pounds

Our Score

4.6
TOP 10

Oregon Fruit Pie Cherries Red Tart

Oregon
3.50 x 3.50 x 4.50 inches
0.91 pounds

Our Score

4.6
TOP 11

Solo Cake/Pastry Filling Raspberry

SOLO
1.65 pounds

Our Score

4.6
TOP 12

Duncan Hines Comstock Original Pie Filling & Topping

Duncan Hines
1.31 pounds

Our Score

4.6
TOP 13

Libby's, 100% Pure Pumpkin, 15oz Can

Libby's
425.00 grams

Our Score

4.5
TOP 14

Solo Filling Prune, 12 oz cans

SOLO
00530025

Our Score

4.4
TOP 15

Borden Naturals Mincemeat Pie Filling and Topping

Borden None Such

Our Score

4.3
TOP 16

Oregon Cherries Red Tart For Pie

Oregon
1.01 pounds

Our Score

4.2
TOP 17

Robertsons Traditional Mincemeat 411g

Robertson's
50172672
2.83 x 2.83 x 5.00 inches
0.91 pounds

Our Score

4.15
TOP 18

Solo Apricot Cake and Pastry Filling 12 Ounce

SOLO
1.55 pounds

Our Score

4.15